top of page
Resume Writing Service
resume writers

ResumeYourWay News

Keep up to date with the latest news from ResumeYourWay.

/ News

  • Writer's pictureResume Your Way

Why AI-Generated Resumes Are a Career Misstep: The Human Touch Advantage

Updated: Sep 21, 2023

Why AI-Generated Resumes Are a Career Misstep: The Human Touch Advantage

Why AI-Generated Resumes Are a Career Misstep: The Human Touch Advantage

In the rapidly evolving world of technology, artificial intelligence (AI) has been progressively seeping into multiple sectors, changing the way we work and live. However, when it comes to resume writing, AI often falls short. At ResumeYourWay, we champion the unique human insight and personalized approach over AI-generated resumes. Much like a fire-grilled steak surpasses a microwave-cooked steak in flavor and richness, a professionally crafted resume brings a depth and authenticity that AI tools fail to replicate.

A resume is more than a list of jobs you've held; it's a strategic marketing tool. It needs a human touch to resonate with potential employers and to narrate your story in a compelling and engaging way—tasks that AI, regardless of how advanced its programming, cannot achieve.

At ResumeYourWay, our award-winning team is dedicated to delivering personalized, high-quality career services. We believe in the power of the human touch, crafting each resume with dedication, understanding, and expertise. By choosing us, you're selecting a partner for your career journey.

Here's why.

AI in Resume Writing: The Inherent Limitations

Despite its remarkable ability to handle large volumes of data and carry out repetitive tasks efficiently, AI still lags behind in areas that require deep understanding, personal touch, and nuanced thinking. The art of crafting compelling resumes is one such area.

Imagine a war scenario. If given the choice between an AI advisor and a seasoned general to strategize your moves, most would lean toward the human expert. This preference stems from the invaluable knowledge, experiential insight, and the ability to react to unexpected developments that humans offer. The same logic applies to professional resume writers over AI. An AI's inability to fully understand and articulate your unique career progression can result in significant gaps, causing your skills and experiences to be underrepresented.

The Human Advantage: A Deep Dive into Your Professional Journey

Unlike AI, a human resume writer engages with you on a personal level, comprehending your strengths, career aspirations, personal preferences, and professional growth trajectory. Your professional journey isn't just a series of data points for them. They recognize it as an intricate tapestry of challenges, achievements, and experiences unique to you.

A human writer uses this wealth of information to create a tailored, impactful resume that authentically represents you. They consider your likes and dislikes, priorities, and the unique value proposition you bring to a potential employer. On the other hand, AI lacks the understanding and empathy to portray your capabilities convincingly. It cannot factor in considerations like geographic cultural nuances, industry-specific trends, or evolving market demands.

The Unmatched Expertise of Professional Resume Writers

Professional resume writers leverage their industry knowledge, professional writing skills, and awareness of recruitment trends to craft resumes that can pass through Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS) and impress recruiters. They stay current with the latest resume trends and job market developments and understand what recruiters in various industries look for.

Despite AI's advancements, it is not yet ready to take over the nuanced task of resume writing. Its lack of understanding of human motivations, inability to adapt to individual priorities, and absence of empathy and personal touch are significant shortcomings. Until AI evolves to overcome these, the human touch in resume writing remains an invaluable advantage.

At ResumeYourWay, we are committed to delivering high-quality, personalized resumes that reflect your unique professional journey. Let our seasoned experts give you the advantage you need in the ever-competitive job market.

AI vs ATS: The Unwinnable Battle

Many modern businesses employ Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS) to manage the influx of resumes. These systems are engineered to filter out generic, mass-produced resumes, exactly the type produced by AI-based tools. It's a virtual lion's den for AI-generated resumes. Due to their inability to create a truly tailored, job-specific resume, these AI products often fail the ATS test. let's delve deeper into the complexities of the interplay between AI and ATS.

The Anatomy of an Applicant Tracking System (ATS)

Applicant Tracking Systems, or ATS, are complex, sophisticated software programs used by organizations to automate and streamline their hiring processes. ATSs serve as a repository for resumes, an initial screener, a scheduler for interviews, and more.

Designed to sift through hundreds or even thousands of resumes at an unparalleled speed, these systems scan for specific keywords, phrases, and other markers that match a job description. Furthermore, many ATSs are capable of conducting semantic searches, which not only seek out specific keywords but also interpret the context in which those words are used.

AI-Generated Resumes and Their Shortcomings

AI resume generators are programmed to compile a person's job history, qualifications, and skills into a coherent resume. However, these AI systems often fall short because of their inability to fully understand the human factor and nuances of a candidate's career.

These AI tools often follow a predetermined formula and use a bank of pre-set phrases and words to describe a candidate's abilities and experiences. Consequently, they end up generating generic, mass-produced resumes that lack the tailored, job-specific nuances often needed to pass the stringent filters of an ATS.

Moreover, AI tools do not have the ability to incorporate contextually relevant keywords and key phrases that align with specific job descriptions. The generic language employed by AI tools can often miss the mark when trying to match the semantic search capabilities of an ATS.

When an AI-generated resume comes up against an ATS, it's akin to an underdog battling a much stronger adversary. ATS systems are programmed to seek out unique, role-specific criteria, while AI-generated resumes tend to be too generic and often lack the detailed context that ATS algorithms look for.

For example, an ATS might look for specific software competencies, scope of knowledge or certifications in the field of IT, while the AI tool might merely state "proficient in software usage." This lack of specificity and relevance leads to the AI-generated resume being cast aside.

Moreover, since ATS algorithms are designed to assess the relevance of the experience to the role and give weightage to the contextual use of keywords, the standard language used by AI tools fails to score points. The inability of AI to personalize and provide context-specific details in the resume leads to a lower matching score during the ATS review, decreasing the chances of the resume making it to the hiring manager's desk. In this battle, the AI's one-size-fits-all approach falls drastically short of the ATS's nuanced and context-sensitive filtering, resulting in a lower chance of the candidate getting shortlisted for an interview.

So, while AI tools may seem a convenient way to produce a resume, their shortcomings become glaringly obvious when they face the discerning and sophisticated scrutiny of an ATS, resulting in what can indeed be described as an unwinnable battle. The personal touch and contextual understanding provided by human expertise still reigns supreme in crafting a compelling, ATS-friendly resume.

The Inadequacy of AI for Federal Resumes

Crafting a resume for federal jobs requires a deep understanding, precise terminology, and a strategic approach. These tasks are best accomplished by the best resume writing services that fully comprehend the complexities involved. A resume for federal jobs needs to be more than a chronological account of your work history; it should align with specific criteria set by USAJobs, the federal government's official employment site.

An AI lacks the comprehension to translate your job history into a compelling narrative that resonates with federal employers. Applicant Tracking Systems can easily discern AI-generated resumes due to their generic presentation and lack of specific role-related keywords. The best federal resume writing services, like ResumeYourWay, ensure your resume is carefully tailored, ATS-friendly, and enhances your chances of being shortlisted.

AI's Failure in Veteran Transition Services

When it comes to assisting veterans in transitioning into the civilian job market, AI-based tools significantly fall short. Veterans possess unique skills and experiences often misunderstood or overlooked by AI.

Transitioning from military to civilian life is a complex process, requiring understanding, empathy, and translation of military jargon into corporate language—skills that AI does not possess. As the best veteran resume writing services, our team at ResumeYourWay has a deep understanding of the military ethos and can craft resumes that highlight veterans' unique skills, facilitating a smoother transition into the civilian workforce.

The AI Downfall and the Triumph of Human Expertise

AI-generated resumes lack the human touch necessary to showcase your unique skills, experiences, and aspirations. Without understanding personal career trajectories, AI often produces resumes that feel impersonal and detached, making it harder for you to stand out from the crowd.

In stark contrast, our team of the best resume writers at ResumeYourWay creates personalized resumes that reflect your unique journey. Keeping a keen eye on job market trends, our writers ensure that your resume isn't just a document but a strategic tool to help you achieve your career goals.

While AI may be a revolutionary tool, when it comes to resume writing, it falls significantly short. Trust the power of human expertise and personalized service to guide you in your career journey. Choose ResumeYourWay, the partner you deserve in your quest for career success.

The Pitfalls of AI in Executive Resumes: Navigating ECQs and TQs

Executive resumes, especially for government roles, require careful understanding and specific documentation, namely Executive Core Qualifications (ECQs) and Technical Qualifications (TQs). Using AI in drafting these resumes can be detrimental to a candidate's chances of securing such high-profile roles.

Federal Government Executive Resumes: The ECQs and TQs Challenge

Executive roles within the federal government demand an exceptional level of expertise and a unique set of competencies. This necessity is reflected in the mandatory submission of Executive Core Qualifications (ECQs) and Technical Qualifications (TQs) along with executive resumes. ECQs, which are universal across the federal government, highlight leadership qualities needed to build a federal corporate culture that drives results, serves customers, and builds successful teams. On the other hand, TQs underscore the specific technical expertise required for a particular executive role.

The ECQs and TQs Dilemma in AI-Generated Resumes

AI-powered resume writers encounter significant difficulties in integrating ECQs and TQs, primarily due to the complex nature of these elements. They are not mere buzzwords that can be sprinkled throughout a resume. Instead, they require a comprehensive understanding of the candidate's career trajectory, accomplishments, and the capacity to present them within the specific framework defined by the Office of Personnel Management (OPM).

ECQs are divided into five fundamental categories: Leading Change, Leading People, Results Driven, Business Acumen, and Building Coalitions. Each category requires narrative statements that provide specific examples where the applicant demonstrated these competencies. AI systems, no matter how advanced, have no real-world experience or nuanced understanding of these categories and thus fail to construct compelling narratives that pass the stringent OPM guidelines.

Similarly, integrating TQs into a resume is a task that requires professional acumen and industry-specific knowledge. TQs are unique to each role, and they detail the specific technical expertise required for that position. AI systems lack the ability to contextualize the candidate's technical skills to fit these unique requirements.

Moreover, both ECQs and TQs need to be presented in the Challenge-Context-Action-Result (CCAR) model, which provides a detailed, situation-specific account of the candidate's leadership accomplishments. The subtlety of the CCAR model and the need for in-depth understanding of the candidate's career path make it an impossible task for AI, resulting in resumes that lack depth, individuality, and adherence to OPM guidelines.

Navigating the Complexities of Military Transition: The Risk of AI-Generated Resumes

AI technology, despite its advancement in numerous fields, reveals glaring inadequacies when applied to resume writing, particularly for federal jobs and military transition services. Its limitations become increasingly apparent when dealing with the complexity and specificity of such resumes, often leading to ineffective, and at times, detrimental outcomes.

Understanding Military Resumes: A Task Beyond AI

Resumes for military personnel transitioning to civilian roles are inherently different. They require a detailed understanding of military roles, accomplishments, and unique skill sets, which often do not directly translate into civilian language. Add to that the complexities of interpreting Verification of Military Experience and Training (VMET) documents, Joint Services Transcripts (JST), and service evaluations, and you have a task that AI is not currently equipped to handle efficiently.

An AI tool lacks the capacity to understand and adequately interpret the depth of experience, the breadth of skills, and the personal attributes gained through military service. Consequently, it often overlooks critical components of a veteran’s career when creating a resume, reducing the potential for a successful transition.

The Expertise at ResumeYourWay: A Blend of Technology and Human Insight

At ResumeYourWay, we combine the efficiency of technology with the invaluable insight of human professionals to create impactful military transition resumes. Our team comprises 60% veterans, which allows us to draw on a wealth of firsthand experience and insider knowledge.

We provide comprehensive consultations for every military transition resume we create, discussing specific accomplishments, duties, and unique value each service member offers. Our veteran writers can understand and interpret VMET, JST, and military evals, converting military experience into valuable civilian skills and competencies that resonate with prospective employers.

AI vs. The Human Advantage in Military Transition Resumes

When it comes to creating resumes for federal jobs and military transition, the human touch is irreplaceable. Our writers understand the language, culture, and unique demands of military service. They can communicate the transferable skills and experiences gained during military service effectively and in a language that civilian employers understand.

In comparison, AI, with its current limitations, lacks this nuanced understanding and the ability to tailor resumes to the specific requirements of these roles. It cannot yet match the empathy, understanding, and adaptability of human professionals who have walked the path themselves.

So, whether you're a veteran transitioning into a civilian role or pursuing a federal job, trust ResumeYourWay. Our blend of technology and human insight delivers resumes that truly represent your unique journey and skills, giving you the competitive edge you need.

Trust the Experts, Not Machines, With Your Career

In the constantly evolving job market, standing out from the crowd is crucial. But when it comes to crafting your resume, the key document that encapsulates your skills, experiences, and value, entrusting it to artificial intelligence could cost you opportunities.

From parsing the complexity of federal job application systems to understanding the subtleties of military experiences, the task of resume creation is intricate and deeply personal. It demands an understanding and interpretation of individual career paths, aspirations, and skill sets – aspects that AI, with its current limitations, cannot adequately provide.

At ResumeYourWay, we believe in the power of human connection, professional knowledge, and personalized care. Our experienced team, made up of veterans and industry professionals, is committed to providing a service that transcends mere data input. We strive to capture the unique essence of your professional journey, translating it into compelling narratives that resonate with potential employers.

AI technology will continue to grow and evolve, but it's unlikely to replace the insights, empathy, and understanding of a human professional anytime soon. So, when you're making the next crucial step in your career, remember the value of the human touch. Your professional journey deserves the individualized care and consideration that only a human resume writer can offer.

Remember: machines may be capable of processing data, but humans excel at understanding people. At ResumeYourWay, we don't just write resumes; we create opportunities. Trust us with your career progression, and let's pave your way to success together.


At ResumeYourWay, we believe that anything less than perfect is unacceptable. Whether you are in military, a senior-level executive, mid-career professional, an entry-level candidate, a government employee in any industry sector, we can help!



bottom of page